Are Website Clicks Enough? We Don’t Think So

In today’s digital marketing space, most agencies boast about the number of clicks or impressions their campaigns can generate. Big, green arrows pointing upward on reports showing increasing traffic are used as proof that a campaign is successful. However, are clicks and impressions alone really enough to determine success? We don’t think so.

Clicks Without Conversions Are Meaningless

While an increase in clicks and impressions does indicate that more people are visiting a website or viewing an ad, it does not provide insight into what those visitors are doing once they get there. Are they taking any meaningful actions like filling out a form, signing up for a newsletter, making a purchase, etc.? If not, all of those clicks are essentially meaningless.

Bouncing Visitors Indicate Issues

When visitors leave a website immediately without interacting, high bounce rates are a clear sign that the website content is not resonating with visitors. Even if click traffic is increasing dramatically, consistently high bounce rates indicate problems. Visitors came but could not find what they wanted or could not easily take the next steps the business wanted them to take.

Tracking Real Conversions Matter More

Rather than focusing solely on driving more traffic, digital marketing campaigns should be optimized for driving conversions. Conversion tracking through tools like Google Analytics allows you to set up and track the events and actions that matter most to your business goals, like form submissions, phone calls from tracking numbers, or online sales. These conversions might happen after multiple site visits across devices, meaning they cannot be accurately tracked through clicks alone. The key events you want visitors to complete should be defined and tracked.

We Focus on Increasing Real Conversions

At RocketStatus, we build all of our SEO and PPC ad campaigns around increasing conversions and real business results rather than vanity metrics like clicks. Defining conversions is our team’s first step when initiating any new campaign.

Why Tracking Website Conversions Are Important

Analyzing Site Traffic with Google Analytics 4

Using Google Analytics 4 (GA4), we can track website conversions like form fills and online sales and offline conversions like calls, newsletter signups, foot traffic, and more. GA4 tracking allows us to connect online and offline data to minimize leaks in the conversion funnel.

We can even assign conversion value to each type of conversion, prioritizing those that align best with our client’s business KPIs. Our team implements comprehensive tracking for every conversion event that matters using GA4 and Google Tag Manager.

Importing Conversions into AdWords

Once conversion tracking is implemented across websites, ads, and devices, we can import those conversions back into Google Ads. This allows us to optimize paid ad campaigns directly around conversions rather than clicks alone.

Google’s AI will automatically improve ad relevance and positioning to convert search terms and audiences better. Our ad analysts can also manually adjust targeting and creatives according to performance data.

Continuously Improving Conversion Rates

By tracking real website conversions over time, we can continuously diagnose drops or plateauing conversion rates to improve page experiences. Whether it is simplifying navigation, adjusting calls-to-action, or creating more supportive content, our optimization efforts always aim to improve conversion rates.

Monitoring organic conversions like call and form tracking allows us to identify gaps where paid ads may also help capture more qualified visitors. Comprehensive conversion data helps us make informed recommendations.

Clicks Without Conversions Waste Budgets

Many agencies focus campaigns around driving more and more traffic, attempting to impress clients with bigger numbers. However, website visitors who don’t convert into customers or email list subscribers aren’t well-spent impressions. A wasted budget goes into attracting website visitors who exit without any meaningful action.

Optimizing for Bottom-Line Results

E-commerce sites need to track sales revenue data. Lead generation campaigns should be monitored for quality submissions. The form should collect emails for future nurturing. Site traffic alone has no direct connection to the business bottom line without conversion tracking.

True digital marketing success comes down to optimizing budgets for measurable results aligned with core business objectives. More clicks alone may inflate reporting vainly while wasting hard-earned marketing dollars. In some cases, fewer highly targeted clicks from aligned audiences actually drive higher returns.

Moving Beyond Clicks and Impressions

In summary, conversations around campaign successes can no longer revolve around driving more traffic and impressions alone in today’s data-driven climate. Key conversion events like sales, leads, and subscribers must be defined, tracked, and optimized. Traffic has no impact if it is not driving conversions.

PPC and SEO agencies that solely tout bigger numbers and green arrow charts without displaying performance against proper conversions should raise flags. Comprehensive conversion data mapping consumer journeys provides actionable insight to inform smarter budget decisions for better returns.

Common Conversion Tracking Methods

There are a variety of conversion tracking methods available today to capture meaningful actions visitors take on websites:

Goal Analytics Goal Tracking

Google Analytics allows for goal tracking tied to page visits, duration, custom events, URL destinations, and more. Common goals tracked include:

  • Newsletter signups
  • Contact form submissions
  • Account registrations
  • Online purchases
  • Video views

Event-based goal tracking can capture micro-conversions all along the visitor journey, identifying sticking points in conversion funnels. Values can also be assigned to goals based on their significance to the business.

Call Tracking Numbers

Dynamic phone number insertion allows for specific tracking numbers to be displayed on different online sources. Call analytics provide data on:

  • Number of calls driven by source
  • Recordings to assess quality
  • Call length indicating engagement
  • Location, demographic, and buyer persona data

Calls are often one of the most valuable conversions but can go untracked without call analytics. Unique numbers by source connect calls to media driving them.

How To Implement Call Tracking In GA4

Campaign UTM Parameters

UTM codes tagged onto landing page URLs allow digital marketers to identify which campaign sources are driving actions. UTMs can track:

  • Paid ad networks
  • Social media platforms
  • Affiliate marketers
  • Email sends
  • And more

These campaign attributes let analysts connect conversions back to media sources and better optimize around best performers.

Connecting Online to Offline Data

Increasingly, digital marketing leaders are linking online attribution data to offline CRM systems and sales processes with data integrations. Connecting web analytics to:

  • POS systems
  • Sales emails
  • Call center software
  • Sales team outreach

Provides a full-funnel closed-loop view tying media to revenue. Lower funnel sales can be traced back to initial digital interactions for true ROI.

Analyze Micro and Macro Conversions

Every conversion should be tracked to build cross-channel consumer journeys. But macro-conversions like purchases and lead form fills should be prioritized over micro-conversions like simple clicks. Optimizing for the most valuable actions aligned to core KPIs generates the highest returns.

Assigning Conversion Values

Simple conversion counts are limited. Conversion values better inform budget decisions based on depth of engagement. Call duration, form quality scoring, sales revenue, and predicted customer LTV help weigh conversions. The most valuable conversions can be optimized for maximizing ROI.

Connecting Value Across Devices

Omnichannel tracking with cookies, fingerprints, and statistical modeling accounts for shifting consumer journeys across devices. Suites like Google Analytics 4 seamlessly attribute conversions to initial interactions regardless of source shifting. Holistic cross-device intelligence better optimizes spend.

Why We Don't Focus on Clicks Alone

Understanding why clicks and impressions alone provide limited value is key to appreciating comprehensive conversion tracking. Even though more visitors come to a website, they will still need to convert or spend more time engaging. Not all traffic drives equal value. Hence, our team focuses on conversion rate optimization rather than driving vanity traffic metrics.

Bigger Numbers Can Be Misleading

Simply showcasing bigger site traffic numbers is misleading. Having 100,000 website visitors sounds exciting but means nothing if only 100 submit contact forms. More traffic could even lower conversion rates if poor-fitting visitors are targeted. We focus on improving conversion rates from qualified visitors over-inflating traffic alone.

High Bounce Rates Show Poor Fit

Driving more traffic to a website from broad targeting likely increases bounce rates. Visitors exit quickly when content is misaligned with their interests and needs. Yet many agencies celebrate bigger visitor numbers despite high exits, revealing targeting issues below the surface. Our strategies hone in on best-fit traffic conducive for conversions.

Not All Leads Are Equal

Higher lead counts also do not guarantee success if quality drops. More form fills could capture junk leads with fake contact data or need more buying readiness. They ultimately waste the sales team’s time rather than boosting the pipeline with qualified prospects. Our goal is driving and nurturing high-quality leads, not inflating volumes alone.

Gaming the System is Possible

Unfortunately, shady agencies often use tactics that game the system to report false success. Tricks like pops-ups demanding email signups, hidden pre-checked opt-in checkboxes, irresponsibly optimistic conversion tracking settings, etc. exist, though they damage consumer trust when uncovered. Our conversion tracking analyzes end goals accurately, providing reliable performance data to optimize spending.

Benchmarking Performance Against Competition

Business never exists in a vacuum. Benchmarking performance metrics against competitors provides context around conversion success. While simple visitor traffic comparisons can be made, deeper analysis assessing the conversion funnel differences offers actionable opportunities.

Research Competitor Websites

We thoroughly analyze competitor websites to identify conversion points leveraged across their on-site journeys. Newsletter signup forms, contact CTAs, chatbots, product demos, etc., provide ideas for new conversion opportunities we can add. If competitors are driving conversions in ways a client site is not, we can replicate and test those approaches.

Compare Google Analytics Data

Google Analytics benchmarks summary metric averages across industries for context. But deeper analysis reviewing typical on-site funnel steps, conversion drop-off points, etc., per niche provides more focused insight. If client conversion rates lag behind comparable sites, diagnosing journey differences informs optimization priorities, whether tackling high bounce rates, boosting add-to-cart rates, etc.

Evaluating Paid and Organic Traffic Sources

Assessing the media sources driving competitor website traffic reveals untapped channels worth testing. Display ads, retargeting, emerging social platforms, and more could expand reach to qualified audiences. Likewise, monitoring competitors’ organic rankings, keyword volumes, and content strategies exposes SEO opportunities to outperform them on topics aligned to conversions.

Connecting Offline Data Points

Offline conversion data like call center volumes, foot traffic rates, and local sales can be harder to access but are crucial for full context. Estimates based on store sizes, third-party data signals, and similar sites give approximate benchmark targets to strive for, informing online media budgets. Every data point to set realistic conversion expectations helps shape strategy.

Setting Data-Informed KPIs

Finally, properly benchmarking competitor performance outlines attainable goals tailored to the market. Rather than generic targets, niche context grounds KPIs in documented conversion rates driving ROI for related business models. Historical averages and forecasting models provide data-backed recommendations for refining media budgets, conversion values, and volume expectations.

How We Track and Optimize Campaign Conversions

With a solid understanding of why true conversions must be tracked and prized over traffic alone, we will outline the comprehensive analytics, research, and optimization processes followed internally here at RocketStatus to accelerate client conversion performance.

Identifying Valued Conversions

The starting point for maximizing conversions is aligning on the specific on-site and off-site actions that best reflect the end goals for each business. Rather than assume objectives, our team directly consults with leadership stakeholders across sales, service, and finance roles to rank conversions by ultimate value-driving profitability.

Quantifying Conversion Value

Secondly, tangible values help weight conversions based on tangible revenue, pipeline growth or customer engagement impacts tied to each action. Approximating deal values, acquisition costs per lead, predicted LTVs, etc., contextualizes conversions. For instance, a high-intent form should carry greater value than a simple newsletter signup. This informs ongoing budget decisions.

Implementing Tracking and Analytics

With core conversions and respective values defined, our engineers get to work implementing end-to-end tracking across websites, apps and offline sources via Google Analytics 4, Tag Manager, and integrated software suites to monitor every conversion event. Client-specific dashboards visualize conversion health measuring ROI.

Researching Influencing Factors

Our team then reverse engineers conversion funnel successes and failures through experimentation and statistical data analysis, uncovering correlations driving performance swings such correlation analysis points optimization priorities whether reviewing page layouts, better on-site personalization, expanded targeting, improved chat functionality, etc.

A/B Testing Improvements

Optimization insights then fuel ongoing split testing of page designs, layouts, copy variations, visual aesthetics, promotional placements, etc., to incrementally lift conversion rates. A/B testing against baseline experiences identifies improvements best resonating with converting segments for wider rollout increasing volumes.

Monitoring Values Over Time

Long-term tracking allows us to monitor conversion rates, values, and revenue returns across monthly, quarterly, and annual intervals as campaigns scale, capturing seasonality trends and external factor impacts. Regular testing continues improving conversions while trend analysis preemptively flags threats from economic shifts and rival competitors.

Connecting Insights Across Channels

Comparing conversion funnel performance across organic, paid, and offline sources highlights gaps to reallocate budgets towards better-performing origins, driving higher quality customers. Improving integrated architecture continuously stitches together cross-channel intelligence under unified analytics for 360-degree personalization.

Optimizing Campaign Creative Assests

We tap into advanced analytics suites like Google Analytics and Adobe Analytics to uncover specific creative variants within ads, emails, site content, etc., showing the highest visual appeal, engagement, and conversions from target viewer groups. Tailoring creative directions accordingly maximizes responses.

Identifying New Opportunities

Lastly, leveraging tools like Google Optimize 360 and session-replay tracking provides heatmaps, scroll patterns, and detailed visitor insights around on-site sticking points that cause abandonments within the conversion process. Addressing experience gaps increases pathway completions.

Why Clients Choose Us Over Other Agencies

In closing, fully embracing conversion tracking and optimization rather than prioritizing vanity metrics positions RocketStatus as a true digital partner for driving measurable business growth rather than superficial reporting alone. Our comprehensive methodology successfully connects media budgets to bottom-line returns across channels.

What is RocketStatus? Well, we’re a lot of things – adaptive, resilient, and maybe even a little bit stressed from time to time. Regardless, we’re here to make a mark. Our team builds digital roadmaps to take our clients from point A to point B – then C, D, E, & F. RocketStatus is your long-term partner for growth. To learn more about our approach to digital marketing, schedule a free call with our team.

RocketStatus Newsletter

Scroll to Top